Bayern Munich 1 Arsenal 0 (3-2 agg): Arteta’s side too cautious? Tuchel to go out on a high?

Three days after losing ground in the Premier League title race, Arsenal were knocked out of the Champions League by a rejuvenated Bayern Munich.

Mikel Arteta’s side lost out to a Joshua Kimmich goal in the second half of a game that was tighter for large parts than the first leg that ended 2-2 at the Emirates.

Bayern’s domestic season under Thomas Tuchel has been a disaster, with Bayer Leverkusen crowned Bundesliga champions at the weekend, but in Europe, it is another story.

Tuchel will leave his post at the end of this season, but he could exit with the Champions League trophy that he won with Chelsea in 2021.

Bayern will face Real Madrid in the semi-final after they beat Manchester City on penalties. It could be an all-German final as Borussia Dortmund play Paris Saint-Germain in the other semi-final.

Our writers break down all the action.

Follow the Champions League on The Athletic…

What happened with Bayern’s goal?

Bayern’s goal came from the flank Arsenal had built their game plan so diligently around. It just wasn’t who they thought it would be doing the damage.

For 63 minutes, Arsenal’s left flank had coped pretty well with the threat of Leroy Sane. He was Bayern’s main attacking threat at the Emirates and Arteta selected Takehiro Tomiyasu and Gabriel Martinelli to counter that — despite the former not starting since December and the latter only starting two of the last 10 games.

The Brazilian winger repeatedly doubled up on Sane, who had only got in behind Tomiyasu once as he tracked him inside onto his stronger right foot.

(Michaela Stache/AFP via Getty Images)

But the goal came from Sane getting to the byline and crossing despite Arsenal having a two-v-one against him.

Ben White was not aggressive in closing down the resultant cross, but Martinelli was caught ball-watching, checking his right shoulder for Sane and forgetting that Kimmich was attacking the ball from deep.

The German got the run on him and it proved a costly lapse of concentration. Arsenal’s left flank was jolted in attacking capacity.

Jordan Campbell

How was Saka stifled for cautious Arsenal?

In both legs, Arsenal looked at their best when they lured Bayern into their press and then pounced.

Tuchel’s side coughed up the opportunity they desired in the first half, the best being when Declan Rice robbed Konrad Laimer, but Martin Odegaard and Kai Havertz chose the wrong option and the attack fizzled out.

It was a recurring theme of poor decision-making when there was space to attack, but Bayern looked comfortable defending Arsenal when they had controlled possession.

Arteta’s side were overly cautious on the ball, with few players ahead of the play and even fewer runs in behind to give Bayern something to think about.

Bukayo Saka was pinned out wide for the whole match and it made it simpler for the unfamiliar duo of Noussair Mazraoui and Raphael Guerreiro to outnumber him, with Ben White reverting to the more conservative role he played in the first half of the season.

It was similar to the issues they faced away at Porto when much of their possession was stale and limited to the first two-thirds of the pitch.

After Odegaard’s shot 12 seconds into the second half, it took them until just before the 90 to have another. That’s not ambitious enough to win in Munich.

Jordan Campbell

Why are Bayern better in Europe than the Bundesliga?

Tuchel replicated the approach that bore fruit in London. Bayern sat relatively deep, ceded far more possession than they would have done in the Bundesliga, and were happy to counter-punch.

Before half-time, the German commentators were unimpressed. “This is supposed to be a home game,” said one of the summarisers, witheringly.

But this is perhaps why Bayern have found the Champions League easier going. Freed from having to be dominant, as they are domestically, and with expectations around this team as low as they have been in recent memory, they have been able to play the role of the underdog.

Their main weakness – a vulnerability to counters and transitions when losing the ball – was effectively irrelevant in both Arsenal games, as they made little attempt to control possession high up the pitch.

Does it make them better in Europe? Better might be the wrong word, but the simplicity of playing in an unambitious way, in a relatively simple system, certainly seems to suit them and has quelled some of their neuroses.

Seb Stafford-Bloor

How did Arteta’s subs work out?

Arteta was noticeably quick to make his substitutes after Kimmich headed in the opener. It was not as early as his first-leg changes when he introduced Oleksandr Zinchenko at half-time, but clear caution to the wind from a head coach who cares so much for control.

Leandro Trossard replaced Gabriel Martinelli at left wing, who had struggled one-v-one against Kimmich despite him not nominally being a right-back. Gabriel Jesus came on for Jorginho, adding an extra body to the forward line and moving Kai Havertz to No 10. The problem in this was losing a midfielder, clearly a necessary evil as far as Arteta was concerned, as Arsenal lost a player in build-up against an increasingly deeper and compact Bayern block.

It did little to change the game or re-energise a fatigued Arsenal, who were rocked by the goal. Passes did not stick and White’s yellow card for a counter-attack-stopping foul summed up Arsenal’s problems in attack. Having avoided defeat (two draws, one win) in the first three games of the season in which they fell behind, Arsenal have lost eight times in a row now from going 1-0 down across all competitions.

Liam Tharme

How did Bayern win the midfield?

The selection of Konrad Laimer alongside Leon Goretzka was a deference to Arsenal’s strength in attack, but it also described the squad shortage Tuchel has been tussling with all season. Without a proper orchestrator at the base of midfield, someone comfortable on the half-turn, who can see the pitch quickly and clearly, the quality of possession from deep is not nearly good enough.

Laimer and Goretzka certainly provided some rigidity. Defensively, they were often excellent and there was a real defiance to the way they ended the game.

There were still warning signs, though, and a reminder of how vulnerable they initially looked against Arsenal’s high press that, going forward, Bayern have to improve the quality of possession that comes from that area. No doubt this was a situational triumph, but Bayern need more technical ability in midfield.

Aleksandar Pavlovic is a fabulous player in the making. He’s homegrown and popular, which helps, and he possesses many of the attributes to be part of the solution. But the deeper texture of this game, if not the result, showed that Bayern cannot afford another summer without reinforcing that position; it’s not possible to be successful without an excellent, all-round No 6 in this era. Even just in Germany, it’s fair to argue that one of the biggest differences between Bayern and Leverkusen this season has been Granit Xhaka and how well he leads his team up and around the pitch.

GO DEEPER

Pavlovic is the homegrown Bayern star bucking trends - and giving them hope

What did Mikel Arteta say?

Speaking after the defeat, Arteta told TNT Sports: “At the moment, it is a really gutted dressing room, very disappointed.

“I cannot find the right words, I wish I had. We have to go through it, we tried against a team that has a lot of experience and, through the tie, the margins were very small. There were moments where we were better, we gave them two goals in the tie and that is a big advantage to give away.

“Today, you could see that the margin for error was zero. We made a big mistake defending the box and we conceded a goal. And then it was difficult.

“It’s the moment to stay with the players and give them support because they are the ones that have taken us on this journey.”

What did Thomas Tuchel say?

Speaking to beIN SPORTS, Tuchel said: “It was a chess game in the first half. Nobody wanted to make the first mistake. Everyone played a bit safe — there were moments for us, there were moments for Arsenal. We encouraged the team at half-time to show a bit more personality and a bit more courage. We were more fluid and played a fantastic second half. We deserved to win.

“It’s always better to play in front of your own fans. With every tackle and every good action, you get the support and it lifts you and gives you a second wind. Now it’s the semi-finals and everyone needs to step up — we need to step up and the supporters need to step up again.

“Today we had three free seats on the bench. On the other side, there were no injuries. We lost our maximum speed from the first match in Davies, Coman and Gnabry. We needed to find solutions and we did it as a team. My biggest congratulations and compliments to the team. We are very happy.”

What next for Arsenal?

Saturday, April 20: Wolves (A), Premier League, 7.30pm UK, 2.30pm ET

What next for Bayern Munich?

Saturday, April 20: Union Berlin (A), Bundesliga, 5.30pm UK, 12.30pm ET